That’s right! Fan favorite Pepper is rumored to be back for the new installment. Naomi Grossman was a fan fave for her portrayal of microsyphalic paitient Pepper in AHS: Asylum. According to a leaked call sheet (Via Huffington Post), Pepper will return for Freak Show. The leaked call sheet has a lot more info on character names etc. But be warned, this could be a fake as we have been fooled before.